Why Athletes Struggle to Build Authentic Personal Brands (and How to Fix It)
The Reality of Athlete Branding
For many, “building a personal brand” has become a buzzword, tossed around by agents, sponsors, and social media gurus alike.
Many believe it’s all about posting polished, high-spec content and waiting for brand partnerships to magically roll in. The reality, however, is far different. As Seth Godin so aptly puts it, “It’s entirely possible the work is shit, but also possible that we failed to be clear on who it is for.”
When athletes struggle to build a brand that resonates, it’s often not because they aren’t posting enough or investing in fancy content. The problem runs deeper—it’s a lack of clarity and connection. They might have the skills, the stories, and the following, but without understanding who their audience truly is, the message falls flat.
This blog isn’t about teaching you to create more content. It’s about challenging how you think about your brand, the connections you build, and the story you’re telling. Let’s dive into the real reasons why so many athletes find themselves at a standstill—and how to move past it.
The Misunderstanding Around “Personal Brand”
Problem: Athletes see brand-building as just a content machine.
In the world of sports, there’s a persistent myth: “If I post often and show enough of my achievements, I’ll attract sponsors.” This mindset reduces brand-building to a numbers game, focusing solely on follower count and likes. But branding isn’t a content machine; it’s an exercise in relatability and connection.
Example: Take a footballer who spends hours each week curating highlight reels, meticulously choosing each clip to show off their best goals or assists. The posts look great, and maybe they even get a decent amount of likes. But after a while, the engagement begins to stagnate. Why? Because fans aren’t just looking for perfection; they want personality. They want to see the human side, the struggles, the journey. The athlete’s brand remains flat because it lacks the emotional depth that fans can connect with.
Truth: Branding is not just output but building a relatable narrative.
Building a brand is about more than just “showing up” online. It’s about telling a story that fans and potential sponsors can get behind. When you shift your focus from posting highlights to sharing insights—your motivations, your values, your setbacks—you begin to create a brand that resonates.
Check out this other blog on the Foundations of Athlete Branding to get to grips with the basics.
The Pitfall of High-Spec Content
Problem: Athletes feel pressured to create content that’s visually impressive but lacks substance.
With social media influencers and high-budget productions everywhere, it’s easy for athletes to feel they need glossy, professionally edited content to stand out. This pressure can lead to investing in flashy videos and high-spec photos that ultimately don’t connect with fans. The content might look impressive, but it often lacks the substance that audiences crave.
Example: Imagine a basketball player who spends a significant amount on a cinematic highlight reel, complete with drone shots and slow-motion footage. It’s visually stunning but fails to engage the audience. Why? Because fans want authenticity—they want to see the everyday grind, the gym sessions, the untold stories. When content is too polished, it can feel distant, like watching a commercial rather than connecting with a person.
Truth: Value comes from showing authenticity, not just spectacle.
Instead of focusing on how polished your content is, think about how authentic it feels. High-spec content may attract initial attention, but it’s the real, unfiltered moments that build loyalty and keep people coming back. You need to find a way of standing out, being more than an athlete and being distinctive in a growing pool of peers.
The Illusion of Effortless Success
Problem: Many believe that brand partnerships happen automatically with enough exposure.
Many athletes assume that by merely “putting themselves out there,” brands will line up with sponsorship offers. This assumption is rooted in the idea of effortless success, where athletes believe that fame alone will bring partnerships. However, in reality, meaningful brand relationships are rarely born out of exposure alone—they require strategy, alignment, and consistent effort.
Example: Consider a lesser-known athlete who doesn’t have millions of followers but has a deeply engaged audience because they share personal insights about mental health and overcoming adversity. While a mainstream sports star might attract big names, this athlete finds themselves approached by brands that value their unique message and connection with fans. Their success isn’t from “exposure” alone but from cultivating a personal brand that resonates with a specific audience.
Truth: Success in branding is earned through patience, strategy, and connection.
Real brand partnerships are a two-way street. It’s not about waiting for brands to come to you; it’s about building an audience that aligns with your values so that partnerships feel natural, not forced.
The Power of Connection and Clarity
Problem: Athletes often miss out on partnerships by not knowing their audience or purpose.
A personal brand without a defined audience is like a game without a goal. When athletes don’t know who they’re speaking to, their message can feel scattered, making it hard for fans—and potential sponsors—to connect. Seth Godin’s insight rings true here: if the work isn’t resonating, it might not be the quality that’s the issue but the clarity.
Example: An athlete focused on mental health advocacy shares content that resonates deeply with young athletes dealing with stress and pressure. By narrowing their focus, they don’t just gain followers—they build a community. Brands focused on mental wellness take notice, seeing a potential partner who already speaks to the audience they want to reach.
Truth: Clearly defining who you're for leads to stronger connections and more strategic brand relationships.
When you understand who you’re creating content for, you attract the right people and brands. Clarity is a magnet for opportunities, guiding everything from content choices to partnership pitches.
Practical Tips for Building a Meaningful Brand
Try this - Shift the focus from aesthetics to authenticity.
To build a brand that resonates, athletes need to shift their focus from aesthetics to authenticity. Here’s how to do it:
Know Your Audience: Take the time to understand who follows you. What are their interests? What motivates them? Speak directly to those things.
Show the Process, Not Just the Highlight Reel: Fans want to see more than just the wins. Show the hard work, the setbacks, and the journey. It’s in these moments that fans find inspiration.
Engage Consistently, but Intentionally: You don’t need to post every day, but you do need to show up consistently. Answer comments, engage with fans’ messages, and make them feel valued.
Focus on Depth Over Reach: An engaged audience is far more valuable than a large but passive one. Don’t obsess over follower count; instead, build quality relationships.
Define Your Core Message: What are you passionate about beyond the game? Find a cause or theme that matters to you and let it guide your content.
Real-World Examples of Athletes Who “Get It”
Some athletes have managed to build meaningful brands not by following trends but by staying true to themselves and their audiences:
Megan Rapinoe: Known for her advocacy for equal pay and social justice, Rapinoe has built a brand that extends beyond soccer. She uses her platform to discuss issues that resonate with her audience, leading to partnerships with brands that share her values.
Jaylen Brown: The Boston Celtics star is known for his intellectual pursuits and social awareness, often sharing his thoughts on societal issues. This unique angle sets him apart from the typical “athlete” brand, and brands focused on social impact have taken notice.
These athletes demonstrate that a strong brand isn’t about being the loudest voice but about being the clearest and most authentic - that being said, whilst social media is not the be all and all, understanding how to use it effectively will dramatically accelerate your efforts to create distinction and promote this at scale.
Redefining What It Means to Be “Influential”
In a crowded market of social media stars and influencers, athletes need to redefine what it means to have influence. True influence isn’t about looking good in highlight reels or amassing followers—it’s about creating connections that last. If you’re an athlete struggling to grow your brand, take a step back. Refocus on your story, your values, and your unique audience.
Make sure you have the basics covered, spend time reflecting on yourself, understanding what it is you want to do, for who and where the opportunity gap is (some more reading on this).
Branding isn’t about shouting into the void; it’s about finding your people and speaking directly to them. When you’re clear about who you’re for and what you stand for, the right brands, fans, and opportunities will find you. So forget the high-spec content and focus on the depth of your message—because that’s where the magic happens.
If you would like to chat further, get in contact and we can schedule a free 30min consultation; or check out the free resources and services available here.
